Oil glut renders industry’s appeal purely relative

Barrel fever. When re’s excess oil, as is case today, it’s easier to pick a winner. Exxon Mobil’s balance sheet and diversification make it appealing, but only on a relative basis. abundance of crude suggests industry returns will only get weaker.

Exxon said on Friday it generated $8.6 billion of net profit in third quarter, as production surged 25% from a year earlier. Much of it is attributable to $60 billion acquisition of rival Pioneer Natural Resources. Falling commodity prices, however, translated into 5% less earnings. Rivals Chevron and CocoPhillips suffered even worse declines, of 31% and 25% respectively, despite extracting more crude.

Gluts augur more of same. Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries and its allies are sitting on record spare capacity. Excluding Libya, Iran and Russia, y had more than 5 million barrels per day available within 90 days and which can be pumped for a sustained period, according to International Energy ncy. It furr estimates that worldwide demand will grow by more than 1 million barrels per day in 2024 and 2025, while supply rises 1.5 million barrels per day in both years.

Most of increase comes from beyond OPEC. U.S. production exceeds 13 million barrels per day, and gaining, making it harder for cartel to trigger a rise in prices.

bigger problem is waning growth in oil purchases. Electric vehicles will exceed 23% of new car sales this year, according to research outfit Rystad Energy, a proportion that promises to keep swelling. It helps explain why IEA projects that supply capacity will exceed demand by 8 million barrels a day by 2030.

For energy-focused investors, Exxon is safer option. Nearly a third of its income comes from chemicals, refining and or businesses. Moreover, net debt of about $15 billion is far outweighed by $74 billion of forecast EBITDA this year, according to estimates gared by LSEG. It also trades at 14 times estimated earnings, only a small premium to peers.

At same time, Exxon’s 90% total shareholder return over past decade – even with its generous dividends included – is less than half roughly 240% from S&P 500 Index. It’s a similar story for Chevron and Coco. As most recent financial results show, even companies sensibly managing capital and bracing for energy transition will struggle when re’s too much oil. Better to drill for investment ideas elsewhere.

Context News

Exxon Mobil said on v. 1 it earned $8.6 billion in third quarter, 5% less than in same period a year earlier, while production increased 25% to 4.6 million oil equivalent barrels per day. Chevron said on v. 1 that it generated $4.5 billion of net profit in three months ending Sept. 30, a 31% decline from $6.5 billion a year earlier. Its production grew 7% from previous year to 3.4 million oil equivalent barrels per day. Both companies said lower commodity prices hurt earnings. Chevron said aver price realized on a barrel of liquids was 12% lower than a year earlier.